One thing that was quickly remarked upon after Apple’s announcements at last week’s WWDC Keynote was that once again Apple had effectively rendered some third party apps redundant, such as most basic ToDo apps.
What was also remarked was the ‘curious’ similarity between iOS 5’s new WiFi Sync feature and a jailbreak-only app that was rejected from the App Store last year. As it was originally submitted to Apple, developer Greg Hughes finds it awfully suspicious that it is now available as part of the OS and with the same name and logo to boot, and is seeking legal advice.
To all this, I say codswallop.
Let’s take a look at this and see why Greg Hughes probably doesn’t have a legal leg to stand on*.
*note: I know little of the law, I am just, as I often do, calling it as I see it.
WiFi Sync vs WiFi Sync. How exactly can Apple think no-one will notice the near-identical names and purposes of these features? But hang on. What, exactly, is it that this new feature of iOS is offering? Syncing over WiFi. How many choices are there for names that explain exactly what’s going on without overcomplicating things? My list comprises of Syncing Over WiFi or WiFi Sync. As you’d expect from Apple, they went for the snappier one.
It goes a little beyond that, of course. This sounds all very similar to the trademark battle Apple is currently fighting over the mark ‘App Store’. Isn’t it a little hypocritical of Apple to defend one mark whilst trampling all over another? Well, apart from the fact that ‘WiFi’ and ‘Sync’ are in common usage and have been for years, while ‘app’ is something that only started to come into use with the launch of Apple’s App Store? Oh, right.
This is already looking like less of a ‘coincidence’ to me. But what about that logo? How can that be explained away?
TUAW raises the notion that the similarity between the two logos is either an ‘amazing coincidence’ or a case of Apple plagiarism. At first, the evidence seems pretty damming. This is the ‘original’ WiFi Sync logo:
And this is Apple’s ‘new’ WiFi Sync logo:
Well look at that. How can Apple possibly think they could get away with this one?
Except, let’s take a closer look at the logo itself. Don’t the elements of both of them look familiar?
Ah yes. It looks to me like Apple’s long-standard WiFi icon inside the almost as long-standing iSync icon. Here they are separately:
WiFi. Sync. This is all starting to make a lot more sense.
So, unless Mr Hughes can provide proof that Apple have in some way stolen the mechanism with which his app worked, he likely won’t get anywhere. Of course, the press do enjoy a good underdog-versus-major-corporation story, so expect them to milk it for a little while, alongside pictures of Greg looking a bit upset. Okay, he doesn’t really pull it off in that example. But still.
One thought on “Why the original creator of WiFi Sync probably doesn’t have a leg to stand on”
I really love your writing style. I’m interested in finding out whether you write professionally or are perhaps interested in contributing to a new site I’m preparing to launch. If you’re at all interested in hearing more, you can contact me at email@example.com, or provide me with your contact details.